Scientists at the Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (CSA CSM) recorded the first measurement of pressure distribution inside a proton and reported in journal Nature that inside every proton in every atom in the universe is a pressure cooker environment that surpasses the atom-crushing heart of a neutron star.
The nuclear physicists found that quarks—the proton’s building blocks—are subjected to a pressure of 100 decillion Pascal (1035) near the center of a proton, about 10 times greater than the pressure in the heart of a neutron star. “We found an extremely high outward-directed pressure from the center of the proton and a much lower and more extended inward-directed pressure near the proton’s periphery,” says Volker Burkert, Jefferson Lab Hall B Leader and a co-author on the paper.
Burkert says that the distribution of pressure inside the proton is dictated by the strong force, the force that binds three quarks together to make a proton. “Our results also shed light on the distribution of the strong force inside the proton,” he says. “We are providing a way of visualizing the magnitude and distribution of the strong force inside the proton. This opens up an entirely new direction in nuclear and particle physics that can be explored in the future.”
Once thought impossible to obtain, this measurement is the result of a clever pairing of two theoretical frameworks with existing data, according to the research team. First, there are the generalized parton distributions. GPDs allowed the researchers to produce a 3-D image of the proton’s structure as probed by the electromagnetic force. Second, there are the gravitational form factors of the proton. These form factors describe what the mechanical structure of the proton would be if researchers could probe the proton via the gravitational force.
The theorist who developed the concept of gravitational form factors in 1966, Heinz Pagels, famously observed in the paper detailing them that there was “very little hope of learning anything about the detailed mechanical structure of a particle, because of the extreme weakness of the gravitational interaction.”
Recent theoretical work, however, has connected GPDs to the gravitational form factors, allowing the results from electromagnetic probes of protons to substitute for gravitational probes.
“This is the beauty of it. You have this map that you think you will never get,” says Latifa Elouadrhiri, a Jefferson Lab staff scientist and co-author on the paper. “But here we are, filling it in with this electromagnetic probe.”
The electromagnetic probe consists of beams of electrons produced by the Continuous Electron Beam Accelerator Facility, a DOE Office of Science User Facility. These electrons are directed into the nuclei of atoms, where they interact electromagnetically with the quarks inside protons via a process called deeply virtual Compton scattering.
In the DVCS process, an electron enters a proton and exchanges a virtual photon with a quark, transferring energy to the quark and proton. A short time later, the proton releases this energy by emitting another photon and continues on intact. This process is analogous to the calculations Pagels performed for how it would be possible to probe the proton gravitationally via a hypothetical beam of gravitons. The Jefferson Lab researchers were able to exploit a similarity between the well-known electromagnetic and hypothetical gravitational studies to get their result.
“There’s a photon coming in and a photon coming out. And the pair of photons both are spin-1. That gives us the same information as exchanging one graviton particle with spin-2,” says Francois-Xavier Girod, a Jefferson Lab staff scientist and co-author on the paper. “So now, one can basically do the same thing that we have done in electromagnetic processes—but relative to the gravitational form factors, which represent the mechanical structure of the proton.”
The researchers say the next step is to apply the technique to even more precise data that will be available soon to reduce the uncertainties in the current analysis and begin working toward revealing other mechanical properties of the ubiquitous proton, such as the internal shear forces and the proton’s mechanical radius.